Subscribe to FeedStandardized Tests - What Are They Good For? Absolutely Nothing?!
Making students accountable for test scores works well on a bumper sticker and it allows many politicians to look good by saying that they will not tolerate failure. But it represents a hollow promise. Far from improving education, high- stakes testing marks a major retreat from fairness, from accuracy, from quality, and from equity.
- Sen. Paul Wellstone (1944-2002)
Standardized testing is quite the hot topic, to say the least. I remember spending pretty much the entire semester of Tests & Measures in college debating the validity of standardized tests.
A lot of educational institutions are being accused of “teaching to the test”. If you have to teach to a test, then obviously the test isn’t really testing what it should be, right?
Standardized tests are used for different purposes. We won’t get into the political purposes right now, but we all know that those exist. In elementary, middle, and high schools, they are used to make sure that students are performing at an appropriate level, and they are used to place students in appropriate courses at the appropriate level. These tests should be testing grade-level knowledge, reasoning and problem solving ability, writing skills, etc. A well constructed test does just that – it tests whether or not the test taker has certain knowledge and skills and can apply that knowledge and those skills.
Special thanks to SideLong for permission to use this photo.
I have seen student records where a student is earning decent grades in math courses like Algebra and Geometry, but then they are unable to pass a state exit exam in math. What is the problem here? Is it that the students are not actually learning the material? Are grades being “given” to students? I find it impossible to believe that a student can earn a B in Algebra I and Geometry and then fail a math exit exam that most likely only skims the surface of basic Algebra and Geometry. Is the test bad or are the courses bad?
The only thing I really have to go on to answer that question is that the tests are standardized while the courses are not. We see students across counties and states performing at or above level in their high school courses and then failing exit exams. What are these tests actually testing? I’m not saying the courses themselves are perfect, I doubt they are. Improvements on these courses that are being made are based on how students are performing on these tests though, and that is a little scary. Courses should be designed so that the student learns and understands the material, and the tests should be designed to make sure they have done just that.
If we are teaching to tests, especially bad tests, we are really failing our students.
Nicole Burris
Associate Registrar
Ashworth University
April 22nd, 2008 at 5:41 pm
Agreed. This is my first time reading AU’s blogspot, and I am glad to see someone with my same experiences and opinions.
My own experiences with standarized tests have been..questionable, to say the least. I personally believe that the standardized tests should, at least, be lowered in level a bit. I remember being in 9th grade, studying Algebra I (advanced), and when it came time for the standardized test, there was mostly Trigonometry on it.
I’m now a senior in AU’s homeschool program, and to be honest, I still know nothing about Trig. How are students to pass a test on a subject they’ve never been taught?